The decision to make.
Approve colour on an agreed physical reference.
A photograph is affected by capture, display and viewing conditions. Use it to discuss direction, then identify the sample or colour standard that controls approval for the actual textile.
Use the right reference.
Record the issuing colour system and exact code separately if used. An unqualified number is ambiguous. For mixed-tone tweed, describe ground, secondary and accent roles instead of reducing the whole cloth to one colour name.
Bring it to the garment task.
Review the complete repeat and the cloth at garment distance. A small contrasting component can look very different in a macro image and in the overall fabric. Keep both observations tied to the same sample.
Produce a usable record.
Record the date, reference version, viewing conditions and approved points. If a colour role changes, specify which other components should remain fixed and request a clearly identified revision.
A worksheet for the next decision.
Scroll the table horizontally on small screens.
| Decision | Record in the brief | Resolve with evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Reference | Exact sample, version and intended face | Physical sample identity |
| Observation | What was seen, measured or trialled | Relevant reference or assessment |
| Requirement | Fixed points versus targets | Agreed brief and actual specification |
| Next step | Specific unresolved decision | Named sample or review task |
Keep these points with the reference.
- Sample identity and version
- Garment and purpose of review
- Relevant measurements with units
- Physical or documentary evidence
- Accepted points and open questions
- Next action and responsible party
Solve the next buying problem.
Why do the photograph and delivered sample look different?
Screen, lighting, camera and image processing can change the colour impression. For approval, compare the physical sample with the agreed physical standard under defined viewing conditions. Keep the sample identity and date. A screenshot should communicate direction, not act as the final textile colour reference.
What should I do when a sample looks right in one light but wrong in another?
Record the viewing conditions and which colours change in relation to the reference. Ask the responsible colour team to assess the actual sample under the intended conditions. Do not resolve the disagreement by sending another uncalibrated photograph. Preserve the standard, candidate and observations together.
The website image and the swatch disagree
Use the image to identify a visual direction and the labelled physical sample to make the material decision. Display settings, image processing and viewing conditions can change what a photograph communicates. Describe the observed difference without treating either screen as an objective colour standard. Keep the image reference and the sample identifier linked so that everyone is discussing the same option. If the buyer only has an image, request an appropriate physical submitted fabric sample before giving a final shade acceptance.
Compare the full mixture, not one attractive yarn
A tweed can contain contrasting yarns, flecks and surface effects that create an overall impression at a distance. Examine both the mixture and the details that matter to the design. Keep the pieces in the same orientation and comparison conditions and consider whether the fabric sample piece shows enough of the pattern. A close-up of one coloured strand may be useful evidence, but it does not by itself describe how a garment front or matching set will appear.
Agree viewing conditions before arguing about shade
Record the conditions used for the comparison and the relevant viewing directions. Where the buyer requires evaluation under specified lighting, make that requirement explicit and use an agreed procedure rather than naming a light source after the dispute begins. If the appearance changes between relevant conditions, document the change and ask how the programme will accept or reject it. Do not assign a numerical tolerance or technical colour label from a casual phone comparison. The acceptance basis belongs in the specification.
A roll matches the target; may it be mixed with another?
Matching the approved reference and matching other pieces in the same garment are related but separate decisions. Ask how proposed lots or rolls will be identified and kept associated with cut components where shade continuity matters. For a jacket and skirt set, review the intended pairing rather than approving each fabric sample piece in isolation. Preserve the physical comparison reference and the permitted grouping decision. A generic statement that both pieces are ‘navy tweed’ does not tell a cutter whether they may be combined.
What if the same fabric looks different when turned?
Check that fabric front side, nap or other directional appearance has not been confused with a shade difference. Compare the labelled pieces in their intended garment orientation. If rotating a panel changes its appearance, record the direction rule for cutting and sample review. Do not quietly rotate pieces to make one comparison pass and then issue an unrestricted cutting layout. Where the effect remains uncertain, request a paired-panel trial that reproduces the intended garment so that the accepted appearance can be communicated clearly.
Use measurements only with their assessment context
If instrumental colour assessment is part of the programme, agree the method, settings, sample preparation, reference and acceptance criteria with the responsible technical team. Preserve the resulting report alongside the visual decision. A number without its comparison basis is difficult to interpret, particularly when several yarn colours or pronounced texture are present. Do not invent a universal colour-difference limit for all tweeds. Also avoid treating an instrument reading as a substitute for checking the appearance of the intended combination of panels.
Keep shade approval separate from colourfastness
A sample can be visually acceptable against a reference without evidence that it meets a rubbing, cleaning or other colourfastness requirement. Write the two decisions separately and connect any requested test to the actual identified material. Use the relevant test question and agreed acceptance basis rather than implying that a successful visual comparison establishes durability. If only appearance has been reviewed, say so plainly. This prevents an image approval or a shade comment from being misread as a complete performance release.
Close a colour issue with a traceable decision
Record the target reference, sample or lot, comparison conditions, overall observation, detail concerns, photographs for communication and the final acceptance or reservation. Keep accepted and rejected versions distinguishable. Where the next step is another submitted fabric sample, state what should change and what should remain fixed. Where the issue affects cut components, preserve their identities before combining them. The aim is a repeatable decision for the buyer and maker, rather than a chain of messages saying only ‘slightly warmer’ or ‘more like the first picture’.
Continue the related decisions
Build a Tweed Colourway
Develop tweed colourways with separate ground, secondary and accent roles and physical approval references.
Read the guideTweed colourfastness: choose the relevant assessment
Scope testing by use and care.
Read the guideTweed Samples: Revisions, Evidence & Approval
Review tweed sample differences, identify each development stage and record what is approved before requesting another sample or releasing production.
Read the guideTweed Quality Review: Defects, Evidence & Decisions
Document tweed defects with sample identity and relevant evidence. Separate appearance, specification and assembly issues before reviewing a correction.
Read the guide